@ZStan99 even simple surgical masks attenuate particles enough to prevent infections. Not as thorough ofc, but it’s hard to imagine that coughing into a surgical mask is as bad as coughing into the air. After all, why would surgeons use them?
@ZStan99 And I think I read something saying that heat is a pretty effective disinfectant for masks if absolutely necessary, but yeah replacing them is better
@ZStan99 imo the medical authorities in the US are wrong, either as a Noble Lie to defend the stockpile of masks from citizens, or they just don’t know
@ZStan99 All I know is that there’s only one clear and visible difference between how the Asian countries handled this virus and how we did it and it’s the masks
@ZStan99 The interesting thing is that Japan has not done much at all in terms of mitigation, but the mask usage is near 100% and that seems to be enough
@jervoris@jdcmedlock Even if they’re under pressure, they will not fold under an e.g. 5x surge on medical mask prices. These commodity items are probably a distant last place in their list of costs
@JustJoshinYou13@browserdotsys the asymptomatic period wouldn’t explain the decline in the middle of the epidemic, as there should be others coming out of their asymptomatic period. it seems that this chart is just nonsense; it’s a strangely chosen sub sample of total cases
This CDC chart that @elonmusk keeps linking to is a huge failure of sci comm. It's plotting cases per day of some arbitrary subsample of cases. There were more cases discovered in New York YESTERDAY than the entirety of cases covered by this whole chart
@browserdotsys@complexifire I think I get it now. I believe these 4k cases are the ones who tested positive at a CDC lab. While the CDC testing/day stays relatively constant, more and more private labs spin up every day. If hospitals roughly split between all the labs, then the CDC lab numbers will go down
@aquariusacquah ok lets say HCQ did work and trump endorsed on tv, some idiot goes and tries to consume it without checking up on dosage and timing. Would Trump still be at fault?
@hoffmanofsteel My entire college career I either watched classes online or didn’t attend lol. Not much would’ve changed for me. I can imagine others may feel different
@THOTCrime time for y’all to make a discord server
anyway yea grad classes are more seminar-ey but the focus of grad school (assuming PhD track) for most ppl is producing research. It sucks if the labs close down but not expecting massive changes to their lifestyle otherwise
@THOTCrime Yes, it is good to admit that the state is first and foremost, fundamentally a protection racket that grows larger and larger since violence has economies of scale
@THOTCrime true global domination produces a vast decrease in violence, that much is true. That’s why all the great periods of peace in history are named after some imperial power. Pax Romana, Pax Britannia, Pax Americana, etc
@THOTCrime i believe that is due to vast material abundance and an era of american hegemony. state powers were very advanced in the 1914-1945 period and spent much of it ripping each other to shreds. it was not a peaceful time. a return to great power conflict will mean a return to violence
@aquariusacquah@ne0agent1c old ppl are profligate consumers of healthcare, and also the slow collapse of the healthcare sector can't be good for everyone else either
@ne0agent1c go to where? i mean even ignoring old people, the healthcare sector will undergo an ugly collapse as they're forced to switch every ward into either quarantine or covid ICU and that level of panic can't be good for anybody
why in the hell would the dose matter? doesn't the viral load rapidly increase via self replication when it hits the body anyway? any virologists willing to sus this one out https://x.com/robinhanson/status/1242655704663691264
@aquariusacquah@hingeloss the fda kinda already does this with the phase 1-3 approach but seems to not encode the concept of urgency/potential gain in a bayesian way
Question. An asset price is falling due to bad fundamentals. You know that if it drops below $x, the govt will bail it out such that it’s worth at least $x + 10. Does the market price ever reach $x? https://x.com/BigBreakfastLob/status/1242684442549686273
@BigBreakfastLob None of that stuff really matters at all for this argument. Assume that something is happening in that industry that makes the stock worth $x-10, like perhaps a global pandemic
I don’t think this crisis emphasizes the failure of free trade / offshoring as much as it does the lunacy of not stockpiling vast quantities of key pandemic defense commodities
@similaralterity@BigBreakfastLob policymakers don’t even hide it anymore. they transparently do whatever it takes to make price go up. If decisions are made based on previous day’s S&P close then you get into a logical loop like the one I described at the top
@WokeDon Rampant QE in the 2011-2020 period has distorted the credit markets past the point of return and left us with no recourse in a true crisis like we’re in now
@LucioMM1@Willyintheworld@RCAFDM this 10x official cases thing is nonsense. we empirically know that the hospitals are flooding, so to explain that fact and a low CFR we'd have to conclude that this is a *tremendously* fast spreading virus
@realjdburnett The CDC’s apparent inability to produce a simple nasopharyngeal test is not partisan though ... I don’t even know who to blame for that. That was our initial sin
@aquariusacquah@noguchilamp knowing no help is coming ensures that every company, every contract has the idea of existential sector level collapse in mind in the planning phase. companies should be prepared to scale down to minimal expenses and go into “stasis mode” at the drop of a hat
@Cullen_OK@similaralterity I don’t see why not, since the kindle is very low margin and they make all their money on ebook sales. They have this desktop app called “Send To Kindle” where you can just drag and drop files that immediately get sent over.
@quinnnorton at some point, you don’t need to do be doing stats to viscerally understand the threat level of this thing. A disease comes around that kills a quarter of people in their prime, and I’m buying guns. True, these are fantasy epidemiological parameters but it’s a movie
@selentelechia my 3rd grade teacher called in my parents to complain about all the above. parents were just confused lol
but tbh i don’t see my time in grade school as unpleasant
@insipidwanker@eigenrobot I can’t speak for everybody but in my experience stuff you get online is always high quality as hell, if you have an eye for reputable sellers and that kind of thing
This moment has freed me politically to speak my mind. I'm not going to pretend that we have any allies. No mercy.
The Toy Story franchise peaked with Toy Story 2 and Pixar continues to beat a dead horse :(
@NicholasElodeon@ironically_edgy@conureCC In the next few weeks we’re about to see that the US healthcare system is indeed the best in the world on the supply side. Will prove to have far more flex capacity than Italy. Employer healthcare is silly tho
@CathyYoung63@cvaldary@vox “expert opinion” usually ranges the entire space of possible viewpoints so vox's journalistic quality is indeed in question. there were epidemiologists at the time screaming into the void whose voices could’ve been signal boosted.
@TheMuddySchmuck@bahstgwamt They expelled them as retaliation for us expelling their diplomats. In the eyes of the Chinese there’s no real distinction between Press and State
@koaleszenz Seems plausible, but if this is true Trump’s feud with gov whitmer doesn’t add up, nor does newfound coziness with Cuomo and all the supplies sent to New York, a deep blue state
@bahstgwamt@stealthbotmk1@TheMuddySchmuck dunno if that’s true. if liberalism is about guaranteeing universal human rights, then it might be liberal to interfere in other countries that are infringing on those rights
@eigenrobot@Stu_de_Stael@granderojo@halvorz I mean it in the Shannon sense
Messages in some medium, quantified by entropy. But that probably creates more rabbit holes than it closes
“Contagion” CDC:
- omnicompetent, finger in all pies
- contact tracing back til the beginning of time
- worst enemy is Jude law
Real CDC:
- can’t make a simple PCR test
- gave up on tracing a week in
- archenemy is their own bureaucracy
@calonyction@Pvelkovsky got it, and is it still feasible when we’re looking at clusters of thousands in a city/state? Is it doable without official confirmations via PCR?
@mattparlmer i don't really have faith that these regional conflicts spell disaster for the CCP or anything. even the best run states have protests from time to time.
@mattparlmer I only say this because it's become increasingly important to me that we don't fall into the alluring trap of thinking that liberalism is inevitable in china and that the people will revolt and demand freedom sooner or later. this facet of neoliberalism has been debunked
@hu__cares@mattparlmer “The common people pray for rain, healthy children, and a summer that never ends," Ser Jorah told her. "It is no matter to them if the high lords play their game of thrones, so long as they are left in peace."
@LiberHomo1 this would be the area where it should be the strongest though. Tbh this is how a lot of “traditional medicine” that kinda sorta works is created: memetic evolution
@pelotom No doubt that the medical system fails quite a few people. I personally have no love for doctors (lots of bad associations). But think about the many cases where the difference between proper treatment and quackery is life or death.
@pelotom My grandfather tried to treat his throat pain with herbal remedies for a long time without telling anybody about his discomfort. When we found out we rushed him into the medical system and they found that it was cancer, still treatable. Imagine if he had waited any longer.
Thesis: patents make drug prices artificially high
Antithesis: patents encourage competition and innovation
Synthesis: govt should purchase drug patents at market price and set them free
@aquariusacquah what are the actual stats for uninsurance deaths in the US?
my utilitarian answer would be UCC, last dollar coverage is more efficient than first dollar coverage
@aquariusacquah I pretty much do think this. We should export much more of our industrial surplus to developing nations. This is why neolibs were so soft on China in the first place
@Noahpinion@mattparlmer Pretty much every country with a functional bureaucracy has no federal paycaps. You aren’t going to steal good scientists/engineers from industry if you don’t have competitive pay.
@mattparlmer@Noahpinion It’s a damn shame that graduating college seniors almost never consider government work unless they’re strongly ideologically inclined. The *maximum* pay for federal employees is lower than the new grad pay at google/fb
@mattparlmer@Noahpinion the labor intensive bureaucracies may benefit the most from removing paycaps. effective management is important and uncommon. there's a reason why industry forks over all that money to middle managers
@DylMeisner Here’s a more nuanced take:
it is one of the best things America ever did to help pull a billion peasants out of poverty. But now we must look for an exit and containment strategy to ensure the survival of the liberal world.
the Yeerks took the gift of "Seerow's Kindness" and used it to spawn an imperial order, quickly spreading across the galaxy and enslaving many planets full of intelligent life. Thus began the Andalite-Yeerk wars, and Seerow went down as the greatest fool of Andalite history. 3/
"Seerow's Kindness" is an ironic moniker: it refers to a moment in the animorphs' mythos where a member of a dominant, advanced alien race ("Andalites") granted incredible technologies to aid a suffering species ("Yeerks") on a different planet. 2/
any of u read animorphs as a kid? straight up one of the best kids series of all time. operatic gritty scifi that pulls no punches. one of the key pieces of the Animorph's mythology was an event called "Seerow's Kindness" 1/
https://x.com/DylMeisner/status/1244061521937723393
the US committed a similar Kindness with PNTR & opening China. We hoped that China would prosper, liberalize, and join the West, but instead we created a tremendous ethno-imperial power whose goals are fundamentally inimical to the US led world order. 6/
Seerow's Kindness alludes to a tragedy at the heart of the game theory of liberal civilizations. We are moral universalists: we feel that all humans deserve the material well-being that has come to us. But our most well-meaning interventions can empower greater evils. 5/
the Andalite "hawks" encoded in their law that another alien species must never be helped no matter how much they were suffering, figuring that they couldn't be trusted with their aid. This sets the basis for much of the story. 4/
Side note: Kindness is not to be interpreted as a retelling of the "white man's burden". We in the West have profited off of *actual* colonial orders in the past, and have come closer than any other nation by miles to a post-racial order. 9/
Of course real world liberal civs are motivated also by their hunger for cheap labor, and have colonial histories they're trying to amend. But the fundamental liberal hope is that even our enemies must be humanized and helped, and that in bulk our Kindness won't go awry. 8/
In the Animorphsverse, the Yeerks are defeated through a *second* kindness, where a dying Andalite "dove" bestows godlike technologies on a handful of humans. In the context of the series, this reflects a fundamental optimism about sentient life. successes outweigh failures. 8/
We in the West also try our damndest to supply humanitarian aid to the North Koreans even if it furthers the DPRK regime's own interests. ditto Cuba and Iran in the obama years. it's entirely possible that some of our Kindnesses will long-term lead to more harm than "good". 7/
Maybe as a direct influence of the scifi I read as a kid, I too share the liberal optimism that as far as Kindnesses go, our successes will outweigh our failures. Nixon and Seerow will both be redeemed. 11/11
I don't really have a lesson or a policy prescription to come out of this, other than that the utilitarian math of "Kindnesses" is very hard indeed. Our assumptions must be updated all the time. It seems now would be a good time to switch from China doves to China hawks. 10/
@Teleonomic@nectarina12 honestly don't like his econ takes anymore. do you remember when his phd advisor roasted him on twitter lol? he called one of his bloomberg articles about macro theory as nonsense. not saying it's authoritative, but plenty of economist complain about his takes
@liminal_warmth i've been afraid to read this for a while tbh. "rationalist" lit often comes off as rly smug. is it different than HPMOR in that regard?
@marthsshinedair I think one of the key things about the series, especially the book “Visser”, was that yeerks are indeed people. They aren’t incapable of coexisting with other peoples, unlike (for example) the LOTR orcs. They’re rehabilitated into society at the end of the series.
@tim_ber_wind no doubt we wanted to ply apart the Sino-Soviet alliance at the time, but it’s clear that that alliance was falling apart on its own. China wasn’t willing to be first mate in the communist order. Generations of China doves afterwards have ensured our close cooperation
@collinofzion I have an uncanny memory for things I read before I had access to the internet 😂. The web fried my brain. I also looked some stuff up to double check
@RCAFDM@Trent_mcbride if cumulative deaths follows a sigmoidal curve, then deaths per day should be a bell curve. Bell curves are not exponential even in the early parts, right? So why is there a straight line on the log part?
@aquariusacquah this isn’t really the flex you think it is. real estate is real estate. Who cares if you build a new building or not?
Sure, the CCP can recruit ten thousand wageslaves and build a shitty warehouse that leaks, caves in, etc. in a few days time. I don’t rly care
"The first story I ever heard about immunity was told to me by my father, a doctor, when I was very young. It was the myth of Achilles, whose mother tried to make him immortal."
@ReginaldPGrant@Chris_arnade I am a China hawk now. but nothing you can say will erase the fact that free trade with china lifted a billion people out of extreme poverty. it's time now for a China exit strategy and rejoining TPP
@aquariusacquah i mean i always assume tankies and nationalists are either useful idiots or part of the grift somehow. the JD Vance / Chris Arande narrative of the 2016 election has completely fallen apart. Bernie Sanders lost ground.
@Chris_arnade@ReginaldPGrant this is almost always a populist scam targeted for your "front row" audiences. raise environmental & labor trade regulation to a level where poor nations can't actually comply and keep all the manufacturing at home
@Chris_arnade@ReginaldPGrant i don't know your position on TPP but I'm guessing you were against it, despite highly progressive labor & environmental clauses
@ReginaldPGrant@Chris_arnade you're arguing against a strawman. nobody denies that PNTR with china hasn't produced a liberal East Asian utopia. it is time to weigh those assumptions again.
@eigenrobot Been reading a ton of horror stories on medical residents subreddit. They’re more expendable than actual physicians, so treated much worse
https://www.reddit.com/r/Residency/
@NicholasElodeon wtf is a left Neolib vs a socdem. Somethings gotta be done to these miscreants profaning Milton Friedman’s name. The blessed band of neoliberals is headed by based Lincicome now. We no longer live in fear
@eigenrobot in China they were incenting ppl to get tested. Small prize for negative test, big prize for positive. Able to gather data effectively this way.
However if you make the prize Too Big ppl may start throwing covid parties lol
@eigenrobot gonna push back a lil and say this: Bill Gates is a face of the “Davos class”. And he’s been on the pandemic train long before it was cool. It seems to me that internecine squabbling among that class has not left the brightest in charge of the loudest speakers
@eigenrobot Many of the technocratic Davos elite are indeed nerds. The tech industry has significant influence among their ranks. It’s funny to think of this but Obama was essentially just a VC bro. The guy read Sapiens like all the other good lil Tech CEOs
@eigenrobot It seems to me there are two separate processes happening: the degradation of press, and the degradation of government. The first is still ruled by “elites”, but the second has in fact moved into the hands of populists.
@eigenrobot@matthew_d_green No, but FB and Goog definitely hollowed out the media industry. They were ad monopolists before, and all of a sudden had to compete with data-rich behemoths
@_Jason_Dean_ We know for a fact that all the American companies with factories in China are opening up, so there’s no doubt that the epidemic is clear. It’s less clear if they lied about the peak statistics during the epidemic but I suspect no
@eigenrobot@Rationalbot@EliSennesh@matthew_d_green low wage workers had precarious lives even before the rise of the gig economy. it's mostly a headfake to shift blame onto tech companies somehow. imo important steps are to decouple healthcare from employment (1) and have a robust welfare state (2)
@eigenrobot@Rationalbot@EliSennesh@matthew_d_green if you ever browse the uber driver subreddits they all hate the AB5 stuff. they'd rather be considered contractors than employees due to the freedom it gives them.
@JesseLucasSaga@eigenrobot@Rationalbot@EliSennesh@matthew_d_green i think this narrative is highly reductive. for example, interstate migration rates are at all-time record lows. why aren't people moving out of dilapidated industrial towns to find opportunity elsewhere? my answer is "zoning law"
@JesseLucasSaga@eigenrobot@Rationalbot@EliSennesh@matthew_d_green last year's econ nobel prize winners say that it's because poor ppl value their location far more than rich people and dislike moving. my question is, why now? why did folks decide to give up on moving for opportunity?
@JesseLucasSaga@eigenrobot@Rationalbot@EliSennesh@matthew_d_green for example, major californian metros are creating tons of service-sector low skill jobs. but, there is a massive outflow of actual low wage laborers due to stark living costs. if SF was actually livable, it would employ 5x the current number of low wage workers
@JesseLucasSaga@eigenrobot@Rationalbot@EliSennesh@matthew_d_green you can't easily move service sector jobs like you can move industrial jobs. for example, if you need to hire a ton of fast food workers for a booming tech town, you can't hire fast food workers in Ohio. ditto uber drivers, home mechanics, etc. etc.
@NikkiHaleyfan@_Jason_Dean_ american populism was a noble tradition but I think there was a serious shift away from the elites with GB II and an avalanche after Trump
@traditionrevolt@powerbottomdad1 Obama was a law school professor, wouldn't you say he was an 'intellectual' and an 'elite'? He was in power for 8 years
@traditionrevolt@powerbottomdad1 He had a coherent ideology. It’s true that his personal charisma was key to his victory but imo that doesn’t detract at all from his “elitehood” lol
Bring in more charismatic high performing elites!
Both political parties should learn the lessons of the past few years and strictly limit who gets to run in their party primaries. Only boring old lawyers taking money from the worlds top corporations from now on
@eigenrobot I honestly don’t think being Good is a valuable metric for people in power. Good men are often bad leaders. See Jimmy Carter. LBJ on the other hand was kind of a dick but an excellent president
@eigenrobot The point of democracy is to align the interests of ruthless geniuses with the needs of the people. I don’t remember who said this but leaders are forced to make trolley problem decisions everyday that would reduce most of us to dust
@eigenrobot true. there's a bit of a coordination problem. a primary is likely to output a candidate who is better able to win the GE than the party's own pick. but they will also stray further from the aims of the party elites. If 1 party decides to do primaries, the other must follow
@eigenrobot I think we're agreeing tho
Party does primaries b.c. they think the process outputs a candidate more likely to WIN, even if they stray further from their aims
@LoicTheStoic Godzilla (2013). Captain America: Civil War. I’m not gonna say some basic shit like Birdemic. I enjoyed birdemic way better than the two I mentioned
@aquariusacquah@tom_c_strand BTC is anticorrelated with gold, which is great b.c. it owns all the rothbardians. if 'a flight to stability' causes sell pressure on bitcoin, it basically confirms what every reasonable person has been thinking, that it's a speculative asset class and not currency
@aquariusacquah@realDonaldTrump i think tiktok is hilarious tbh i'm mostly joking. but it would be a blow to china. I don't see why we should allow their social media companies inside our borders when they don't do the same
It’s not a noble lie. Never attribute to malice what can be attributed to ignorance. The CDC guidelines have been the same for *years*, before there was any sort of mask shortage. They just don’t know. https://x.com/webdevMason/status/1244790665038295040
@generativist not sure this is completely true, because UberEats is offering completely free shipping for me. that tells me demand has somehow fallen for whatever reason. unless it's a marketing ploy?
@generativist I think this "living under the API" thing is net good for efficiency. It should absolutely be the case that we should be able to scale up certain real world operations based on supply and demand. These companies should scale up hazard pay if they want supply and demand to meet
and it's very clear what the failure mode they fell into is. There aren't any high powered RCT's proving the effectiveness of masks in a pandemic setting. But absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
@Aelkus@generativist with the current level of unemployment insurance, the hazard pay will have to be very high indeed to get the Instacart and UberEats people actually working.
@Aelkus@generativist since demand is also purportedly rising, this isn't necessarily a bad thing for the market maker. High oil prices mean oil gas stations make a killing. High interest rates mean banks make a killing.
@similaralterity@TheAgeofShoddy I think, for example, the lawyers that comprise the political elite did indeed have to work to build their lawsuits. These are exercises in formal logic and not really “tawking” in the twitterati sense.
The Press elite are a different story
@similaralterity@TheAgeofShoddy The press have always been tawkers of the highest order. As ratatouille puts it, “the bitter truth we critics must face is that, in the grand scheme of things, the average piece of junk is probably more meaningful than our criticism designating it so.”
the 5000 follower cap sucks ass ... making me treat every follow as a valuable resource. just let me follow everyone and let the timeline algorithm do its magic!!!
@guacamolebio is diagnosis really a significant problem though? a doctor can easily make the judgement the NN would make and write down “suspected COVID”
@_vivalapanda@ne0liberal I bought $BYND at IPO. Then I actually went to a store and bought a beyond burger. It was so awful that I immediately sold my stock lol
v jelly reading other people's accounts of tripping bc tbh acid hates me. last I tripped, I basically end up mainlining concentrated nihilism. Like sticking my tongue on the cosmic flagpole. it gave me the Ozymandiaspill: man proposes and god disposes.
@DukakisDude I think that’s just what it was like in medieval Europe? 🤔
Constant plagues and whatnot, mostly bucolic living with a few “cities” that only have a few thousand people
the thing I see most often w other ppls accounts is acid overclocking the pattern recognition / meaning making functions of their brain. Everywhere they look they see new meaning. For me, everything became devoid of meaning. Like Sartre's Nausea.
@StephenRowe0 Since the epidemic is over in China, you would expect the death:cases ratio to be higher. Elsewhere, there are ongoing cases that will eventually result in a death
@DavidKoggan I don’t blame her tbh, she’s pretty young and I think being Too Online has rotted her brain a bit. She seemed nice at first and willing to engage with all kinds of ppl, which is what pol twitter is all about in the first place.
@DavidKoggan It’s v easy to get way too caught up in twitter and start taking this shit seriously. Just have to keep in mind that most of us are completely powerless shitposters lol
@DavidKoggan When you’re online 24/7, there’s no sense kidding yourself that you’re being productive tbh. It’s not mild escapism at that point, it’s your whole world. I’m guilty of this too
what the fuck man apparently in 2016 I bet a friend $100 that there would be no “significant rise in all cause mortality during the trump administration”
@eigenrobot theres clearly a vast gradation of quality even among self-styled experts. Im sure there are many who’ve called nearly everything that's happened. the problem becomes how to identify these folks beyond just degrees and titles
@eigenrobot tbh the market malfunction has been the most alarming thing for me. the VIX didn’t even start ticking up until late feb! A rational market would’ve at least predicted *uncertainty* long before that
@neolibureaucrat@eigenrobot a perfectly foresighted market would’ve known in advance that a pandemic and closures were coming. Prices would plummet in January. An acceptably rational market would have seen slightly depressed prices and implied volatility increase to account for pandemic risk
@neolibureaucrat@eigenrobot The responsibility for Columbia was not public info either tho. Prices at their best should aggregate knowledge from the best informed market participants
@FrancoLMij much of the west basically relies on us to give them guidance for pandemic response. See the responses of Singapore and Taiwan for what an admirable pandemic policy looks like
@mechanicalmonk1@averykimball The shape and structure of a neural net is its prior. A convolutional net has a prior for 2d spatial patterns. A transformer has a prior for word inter-relations. So, the priors are chosen by the researcher instead of evolution
@nseth3 that’s just the thing though. As far as I’m concerned, there is no objective meaning. Meaning is mostly socialized in and self built. What use is it toppling one variety and building another?
amazing to me that we employed PRISM and other hilariously authoritarian responses to 9/11 but when it comes to a disease that's gonna kill a hundred times more people, we're all of a sudden hung up about anonymizing contact tracing
https://techcrunch.com/2020/03/29/test-and-trace-with-apple-and-google/
@ne0agent1c@rivatez I think you’re projecting bc I don’t think that Rothbard is insane. He’s just a prominent member of the Austrian school, like Mises
@Cullen_OK@ne0liberal overall folks on twitter make a big deal about Vox getting stuff wrong for the same reason that Trump complains about CNN a lot ... because they read it / watch it. Vox is relatively powerless in this game, I agree
@Cullen_OK@ne0liberal I think this is a bit of a feint b.c. even among experts there was vast disagreement about how severe this might be. Choosing which experts to defer to is itself a editorial decision that we can question. Balaji documents here:
https://x.com/balajis/status/1228447950084493315?s=20
@PereGrimmer clearly not rigged against the intelligent. just seems that it also requires conscientiousness. Getting a good class grade is an ongoing project that requires time, dedication, and responsibility. an SAT is finished in three hours
@Bugs_Meany@varun_santhanam@ne0liberal 99% of evil in this world exists because of systems level failures, where no one organism in a complex ecosystem knows the crimes the system as a whole is committing. See: '08 financial crisis. If one does understand that something is wrong, it's important to speak up
@PereGrimmer During 9th grade (Waves 1 and 2), students took several standardized achievement tests designed assessing knowledge required to function effectively in modern society: reading competence (RE), mathematical competence (MA), scientific competence (SC) .."
seems like a german SAT
@PereGrimmer SAT stood for 'aptitude test' long ago, but they changed it. It's since been called 'Scholastic Assessment Test' and the self-referential 'SAT Reasoning Test' and then just 'SAT'.
AFAIK it's pretty commonly accepted that SAT and ACT are well correlated with IQ.
@PereGrimmer when I was in school, the grade level assessment tests were different from state to state in the US (now harmonized by Common Core). They're pretty strongly modeled off ACT/SAT. For example, ACT has a science, reading, and math category (same as the germans)
@ne0agent1c@PereGrimmer ive yet to see the evidence for this tbh. since the moment i started going on reddit and twitter it became clear to me that most people in these corners of the internet feel that they're inconvenienced genius slackers. statistically it seems unlikely that they all are